bench

bench

Pages

Friday, May 29, 2015

The other side....PRO Beard Policy

To beard or not to beard?

Walking around BYU campus is like looking in a bowl full of jellybeans: I see many different kinds of people.  However, the thing that catches my eye the most is when I see a male student with facial hair that is not in line with the Honor Code.  When I see this, I think to myself, “How is he getting away with that?”  I’ve never experienced a person being turned away from the testing center because of facial hair violations, but I know that it happens.  Many students prefer to have facial hair, which is against BYU’s Honor Code.  And so I ask, how does BYU impact their students by maintaining their Honor Code standards on facial hair?



BYU has set standards for a reason.  They don’t want to be like the rest of the world.  They want their students to stand out amongst the many people in today’s society. BYU administrator, Lawrence Benson, said, “Beards do not belong here at BYU.  They are a way of expressing individual difference and uniqueness.  But what we are going for here at BYU is to repress our inner selfish desires and conform to what the Lord wants us to be.”  At this point in time, the Lord has said that beards are not allowed on campus.  If we, BYU students, follow the rules that have been given to us and that we agreed to follow, it will be beneficial in providing life lessons.

In the 1970s, the beard policy was in place because beards were associated with hippies, druggies, and protesters.  One could argue that beards don’t have that same association any more and so BYU should change their standards.  However, beards can be associated with similar and same things such as homelessness, hipsters, rebelliousness, terrorism, and druggies.  If you see a man with white hair, a long white beard, and some scrubby looking clothing, you see a homeless man.  If you see a man with white hair, a long white beard, and a red suit, you see Santa Claus.  The only difference between a homeless man and Santa Claus is a red suit. 

One life lesson that we can learn is that we need to associate ourselves with good things.  Satan tries to get us little by little.  Something that my husband and I have recently noticed is the growing popularity of the shirt with an upside down star on it.  We found out that the upside-down star is a symbol of Satan.  A person that doesn’t support Satan probably would not wear that shirt just because it looked cool if they knew the meaning of it.  Now I’m not associating beards with Satan, I’m just trying to make a point that we need to uphold our physical appearances.  “A let-down in personal appearance has far more than physical significance, for when ugliness gets its roots into one part of our lives it may soon spread to every other part.” (The Quest for Excellence, Bookcraft, p. 38.)  By maintaining their standards, BYU is allowing its students to uphold their physical appearance.

To go along with physical appearance, we’ve been told to model our dress and grooming after the apostles and prophets of the church.  Elder Nelson said, “To bear the priesthood means you have a personal responsibility to magnify your calling.  Let each opportunity to serve help to develop your power in the priesthood.  In your personal grooming, follow the example of the living prophets.  Doing so gives silent expression that you truly comprehend the importance of the Holy Priesthood, after the Order of the Son of God.”  By following the example of the living prophets in our personal grooming, we learn that we need to look to them in all things.  If we can follow after them in one simple thing, it will make it easier to follow their counsel on other things that are more important.  According to one of my previous stake presidents, it is an unwritten rule that stake presidents and bishops should not have facial hair.  It is also a rule that in order to be an ordinance worker at the temple, you have to be clean shaven.  As we follow the example of the prophets and those we see leading us in our congregations, we also set an example for those around us, specifically those that we will be parents to.

With BYU maintaining their standards, it also teaches us ways to be good parents.  Just because our kids are throwing tantrums or disobeying rules, does not mean that we adjust and make our rules the way they want them.  As a parent, you don’t immediately give in to your children.  It will make it look like they can disobey rules and throw tantrums and then you will allow them to do whatever they were throwing a tantrum about.  When a child is objecting to rules you have set, you look at the rules and decide later whether you need to adjust your rules or not.

Another life lesson BYU teaches us is that just because everybody else is doing it doesn’t make it cool or right.  If that were the case, cohabiting would be allowed, premarital sex would be allowed, and BYU would sell caffeinated drinks on campus.  The only one in that list that is not church doctrine is the caffeine.  The prophets have never stated that caffeine is against the word of wisdom, yet BYU still does not sell it on campus.  Maybe we should petition for BYU to change that standard as well.  Even if we did, it’s probably not going to happen anytime soon.

One last lesson we can learn is obedience.  Just because we don’t understand a rule or don’t want to follow it does not mean that we can disobey that rule.  Whether we are at home, work, school, or church, we have to obey the rules.  If there is a certain dress code at your work and you decide one day that you don’t want to wear your uniform so instead you wear your everyday clothing, you could probably get fired from your job.  So you decide to follow the dress code because you don't want the consequences of not.  We can learn to follow the rules, or we can learn to follow them later.  For me, I’d rather take the casserole out of the oven now before it gets burnt.


BYU is a great example of upholding their standards and not giving in to peer pressure.  They have not lowered their standards just because someone asked them to.  BYU continues to make sure that they stand out against the backdrop that many people are trying to blend in with.  The students at BYU will continue to learn life lessons as they follow the standards that BYU has set for them.  Now if only we can do that.  With all this, what other life lessons can you learn from BYU’s actions?

One side...CON Beard Policy

To Beard or Not to Beard?

Walking around BYU campus is like looking in a bowl full of jellybeans: I see many different kinds of people.  However, the thing that catches my eye the most is when I see a male student with facial hair that is not in line with the Honor Code.  When I see this, I think to myself, “How is he getting away with that?”  I’ve never experienced a person being turned away from the testing center because of facial hair violations, but I know that it happens.  Many students prefer to have facial hair, which is against BYU’s Honor Code.  And so I ask, how does BYU impact their students by maintaining their Honor Code standards on facial hair?

First of all, let’s get our facts straight.  Here is what the Honor Code states about facial hair: Sideburns should not extend below the earlobe or onto the cheek.  If worn, moustaches should be neatly trimmed and may not extend beyond or below the corners of the mouth.  Men are expected to be clean-shaven; beards are not acceptable. 

Back in 1971, Elder Oaks spoke to BYU students when he was the President of BYU. He said, “Unlike modesty, which is an eternal value in the sense of rightness or wrongness in the eyes of God, our rules against beards and long hair are contemporary and pragmatic.  They are responsive to conditions and attitudes in our own society at this particular point in time.  Historical precedents are worthless in this area.  The rules are subject to change, and I would be surprised if they were not changed at some time in the future.”  Also during his talk he said that the policy was in place because if a person had a beard, it was a symbol of the hippie and drug culture.  This is no longer the case.  Beards are now a trendy style.  Practically everyone who can have one, has one.  Elder Oaks himself said that the policy will most likely change in the future.  Well, it’s the future.

Lawrence Benson, a BYU administrator, said, “Beards do not belong here at BYU. They are a way of expressing individual difference and uniqueness. But what we are going for here at BYU is to repress our inner selfish desires and conform to what the Lord wants us to be.”  I don’t completely agree with this statement.  I honestly don’t think the Lord really cares about whether men have a beard or not.  In 1st Samuel chapter 16 verse 7 it says, “…the Lord seeth not as man seeth; for man looketh on the outward appearance, but the Lord looketh on the heart.”  If intentions and actions are good, then it shouldn’t matter if a person has a little stubble on their chin.  Instead of worrying about if guys are shaving or not, we should worry about if students are cheating or not.  I know it’s easier to tell if someone didn’t shave that morning rather than if they plan to cheat on a test, but if they are, it’s them that should be turned away from the testing center.

I’ve heard another argument that states that being clean-shaven represents a more “professional” look.  Of course, if I were a guy, I probably wouldn’t go to my first job interview with stubble.  However, facial hair is becoming more accepted in the business world.  In a study, results “showed positive estimations of social/physical attractiveness, personality, competency, and composure for the men who wore facial hair.”  The men in the study were hiring managers for companies and were shown 6 different ink sketches of men either clean-shaven, with moustaches, or with beards.  It was just a first impression that they were recording.  Therefore, a person with facial hair might give a great first impression, but then they could totally bomb the interview questions.  BYU should stop focusing on first impression material, like facial hair, and instead focus on actual interviewing skills.  If a person gives a bad first impression, they can always change it around with an awesome interview.





What I’m trying to get at is the fact that because of BYU’s actions, we are focusing on a little thing that does not matter.  It is not a sin to have facial hair and we aren’t going to get kicked out of heaven for having it.  Just let us out of the “No Beard Zone” and we can get on with our lives and focus on more important things than whether or not we can grow hair on our faces.